An ‘earful’ of AI

In his latest column published in the Guernsey Press, Bailiwick Data Protection Commissioner Brent Homan shares a story about how a water-plugged ear resulted in a positive AI experience.

Earful of AI

It was my second year taking part in that long standing and much-loved Guernsey event, the Swimarathon. Along with my teammates, we did St Martin’s Church proud as we completed 44 laps and raised funds for Guernsey charities.

I left grinning, although with a little pool water lodged in my ear. No big deal. I have been a swimmer all my life; it comes with the territory.

But Saturday became Sunday, Sunday became Monday, and still my ear refused to clear, no matter how vigorously I shook my head like a shaggy dog. By Wednesday, I could hear virtually nothing through my left ear. It was time to see a doctor.

Luckily, Queens Road slotted me in for the last appointment of the day on Thursday. Finally, relief was on the horizon!

Well past 5pm, Dr. H greeted me with a smile.  The first thing he did was ask whether I was comfortable with AI being used to record and transcribe our consultation. More importantly, he explained why: if AI took the notes, he could give me his full attention. I was all for that, so the answer was a hearty “yes”.

Now down to work.  I explained my swim-induced predicament and he peered into my ear.  I will spare readers the graphic details but suffice to say the man was an ‘ear-artist’, and after about 10 minutes of microsuction - ‘hallelujah’ I could hear again!  After springing off the table with a sense of rediscovered youth, I was about to leave when my ‘Data Protection Commissioner curiosity’ kicked in.  So, I asked him – what happens next with my AI recording? 

Now, did I mention that I was Dr H’s final appointment after what had undoubtedly been a gruelling day? He would have been entirely forgiven for ushering me towards the door so that he could get home in time for tea and The Traitors. But no, the good doctor invited me to have a seat.

Then Dr. H showed me the transcript that AI had generated during my visit, explaining that some of the sentences were nonsense so he would delete them and when he was satisfied with the summary he would copy and paste it into his official records. “What happens to the AI recording?” I then asked.  “I immediately delete it after each visit!” he responded. And what happens if you get distracted and you forget to delete it? Not a problem – the medical centre has it set up so that recordings are automatically deleted within 24 hours.  All I could say at that point was “Bravo”. 

This, my friends, is what thoughtful, human-centred use of AI can look like:  

  • Using AI in a manner that improves your treatment of patients – Check!
  • Being transparent about its use and seeking consent – Check!
  • Ensuring that the AI record is accurate and fixing any errors – Check!
  • Explaining the AI process to me in plain language – Check!
  • Deleting the AI recording when no longer needed – Check, Check, Check!

So there you have it: from a plugged ear to an encouraging encounter with AI.

Much of the public conversation about AI understandably focuses on what could go wrong. But this experience shows what can go right when technology is introduced openly, used for a meaningful purpose and kept firmly under human supervision.

The AI did not replace the doctor. It allowed the doctor to spend more time being a doctor.

Thank you, Dr H, and well done to the team at Queens Road. As an aside, I can now hear better than I have in years!